Attorney General Pam Bondi has woefully mishandled the Jeffrey Epstein files controversy. It’s clear she should not be America’s chief law enforcement officer.
Trump says AG Pam Bondi can release all ‘credible’ Epstein documents
President Donald Trump said Attorney General Pam Bondi can release all ‘credible’ Epstein documents.
The second Trump administration has been dealing with a scandal for days following its handling of the Jeffrey Epstein case and the file that has turned into a sticking point with the MAGA base.
Conspiracy theorists are frustrated that they haven’t gotten the information they claim exists, and ordinary Americans are likely frustrated that the Trump administration has spent its time appealing to conspiracy theorists in the first place. But nobody is feeling the heat from both sides more than Attorney General Pam Bondi.Â
The depth of Bondi’s mishandling of the Epstein files is not completely clear yet. What is clear is that she is not up to the job of attorney general and the weight of responsibility that comes with it. President Donald Trump may not fire her, but it’s obvious she should never have been appointed to the position in the first place.Â
Pam Bondi’s Epstein blunder is concerning, no matter how you look at it
There are two possible storylines for Bondi’s role in the Epstein list scandal.
The first, less likely option, is that upon reviewing the Epstein documents, Bondi decided that the information needed to be covered up. This would immediately disqualify her from remaining the attorney general. But that’s not what I believe happened.
The alternative option, which I think is what actually happened, is that Bondi made overzealous promises to the right-wing conspiracy crowd and could not deliver on her conspiratorial claims.Â
Conspiracy theorists often end up eating their own. Once the amount of evidence coming to light is less than satisfactory, they inevitably have to find who is covering up the rest of the information that would ultimately prove the conspiracy true.Â
Bondi screwed up by making promises that she could not keep, such as stating in an interview that the Epstein list was on her desk. Overextending her position on the Epstein files only strengthened the idea of a conspiracy.
The administration mistakenly assumed that MAGA would just provide cover fire for them without consequence, as has happened in the past. The difference is that their base is actually holding them accountable. They believed the administration when it promised to release everything on Epstein. This means they won’t sit by and let Trump off the hook the way they might for other stuff.
Regardless of what the truth ultimately is, Bondi is unfit for the position of attorney general. Her behavior has made it clear that she should not be America’s chief law enforcement officer.Â
Bondi is testing Trump’s loyalty to his Cabinet members
Bondi’s tenure will only last as long as she isn’t creating additional problems for her boss. But while she’s running out of space, it’s not all that clear that Trump will fire her as of right now. If he doesn’t fire her, it shows he cares more about escaping responsibility and accountability than he does the negative news coverage or a possible MAGA uprising.
The Epstein story is particularly embarrassing for Trump, both politically and personally. Even if Trump had no involvement in Epstein’s crimes, it is still bad for the president to be in this conversation and for pictures of the two men to be constantly in news coverage.Â
Trump is now in a bind. He can’t fire Bondi because it would require acknowledging that his administration screwed up in their handling of the Epstein files, but her ongoing presence in the administration continues to stain his administration.
Trump doesn’t have many good options, but the reality is that Bondi can’t handle the job, regardless of what the truth ultimately reveals in the Epstein saga.Â
Dace Potas is an opinion columnist for USA TODAY and a graduate of DePaul University with a degree in political science.
